Skip to content

Shults Insurance Agency

Shults Insurance Agency


About Us

As a local, independent agency, we are committed to being here for you when you need us most, with protection for the things you've worked hard for. By representing dozens of national and regional carriers, including Allstate, Travelers, and Progressive, we can guide you to the best coverage at the best price for your unique needs. Stop in to either office for a quote on your home, auto, or business.

A tradition of service:

Our agency has been caring for customers since 1854. Originally opened by Dewitt Shults as a compliment to his law practice, we remain in our original location at 3 Canal Street in Fort Plain. With a second location in Johnstown for your convenience, our professional, experienced staff of 20 has over 270 year of combined experience in the insurance industry.

We are proud to provide the kind of service you would come to expect from a locally owned company, while giving you the options and advancements you would expect from one of the big guys. Whether you’re looking for auto, home, or business insurance, our knowledgeable and friendly agents can guide you every step of the way.


Johnstown Office
Fort Plain Office
Gallery Image Final_11_11.jpg

Rep/Contact Info

April Johnson
Brenda Krutz
Tammy Sorensen

Scroll To Top